Accounting treatment for FVOCI Instruments
Is there any difference between the accounting treatment for equity instruments and debt instruments classified as Fair Value Through Other Comprehensive Income (FVOCI)? The answer is ‘yes’. Frequently participants in my class ask me the underlying reason for such a difference in the accounting treatment when both these types of financial assets are classified as FVOCI.
Equity instruments
The classification criteria for equity instruments and debt instruments are entirely different. Equity instruments can be classified as either Fair Value Through Profit or Loss (FVTPL) or FVOCI. The investor can exercise the choice without undue delay, provided the equity instruments are not meant for trading purposes. There are no other criteria. The important point to note is that the classification is based on the choice exercised by the investor and is not governed by any criteria specified in the standard other than that it should not be meant for trading purposes. The choice however is irrevocable. The unrealised profits or losses from equity instruments that are classified as FVOCI are presented in the other comprehensive income.
Let us examine the reason as to why someone would want to classify an investment in equity investments as FVOCI asset. The predominant reason is to ensure that the fluctuations in the fair value of the equity investments do not affect the profit and loss account. Nevertheless, the unrealised profit on such investments belong to the stakeholders and hence should be reflected as part of the net worth of the shareholders. That is why the unrealised profits are taken to the other comprehensive income reflecting the same as reserves.
If the predominant reason for such a classification is to avoid the volatility in the profit and loss account, then the very purpose of granting such a choice to the investor would be defeated if the requirements where to insist on such profits or losses to be considered in the profit and loss account when such investments are liquidated. In other words, it would be illogical to say that the unrealized profits should be considered in the other comprehensive income, but the realized profits should be considered in profit and loss account. And hence there is no requirement for the realized profits to be routed through the profit and loss account. This is the reason as to why the unrealised profits or losses that are parked in the other comprehensive income is not ploughed back to the profit and loss account even after such investments are liquidated by the investor.
Debt instruments:
For a debt instrument, the classification into FVOCI is predominantly driven by the set of criteria that are specified in the standard. There is no choice that is granted to the investor as in the case of equity investments.
A debt instrument would be classified as Amortized cost asset if it satisfies SPPI test. Further the Business Model Objective should be to hold the asset for collecting contractual cash flows only. An entity should assess whether contractual cash flows are Solely Payments of Principal and Interest (SPPI) on the principal amount outstanding for the currency in which the financial asset is denominated.
If the SPPI test is passed and the business model objective is to collect contractual cash flows and also to sell the same, then the classification is FVOCI. Debt instruments classified as FVOCI, are likely to be sold at any time by the investor. Since it can be sold at any time, the balance sheet should show the fair value of such investment in debt security. The unrealized profit or loss belongs to the shareholders of the company and hence should be reflected in the reserves of the company and more specifically the other comprehensive income.
However, since the debt instrument may or may not be sold, the realisation of profits/loss on such investment is not assured till the time the liquidation happens. And when such a liquidation event happens then the profits/losses are crystalized and should be shown in the profit and loss account.
This is the reason why the unrealized profits/losses are taken to the other comprehensive income initially and when the liquidation happens, the same is ploughed back to the profit and loss account.
No post found!
Effective Rate of Interest – EIR
Are RBI circulars relevant for ECL computation as per Ind AS 109?
What is a Financial instrument?
Is there a choice to designate as FVTPL?
What are treasury shares and how are these presented
Contract to deal in non-financial item
Can a corporate entity still follow settlement date accounting?
Gains and losses on assets measured at FVOCI
Separately accounting for an embedded derivative
Derecognition of a financial asset
Foreign currency risk in a firm commitment as a fair value hedge
Treatment of transaction costs
Derecognise financial assets/financial liabilities retrospectively
Modification of contractual cash flows
Own use exemption as per the Accounting Standard
Difference between amortised cost & held-to-maturity
What is the concept of effective interest method?
First-time adoption while classifying a financial instrument
SPPI test & business model objective test
Current standards for financial instruments as per AS?
Contract is settled through the entity’s own equity instrument
Financial asset categorised as FVOCI
What is an embedded derivative?
Impairment model for different categories of financial assets
Ind ASs relating to financial instruments
FVOCI (equity instruments) and FVOCI (debt instruments)
Classification of derivative instruments
Reclassification of a financial asset
Debt instrument measured at FVOCI
Change in contractual cash flows
Loss allowance as per Ind AS 109
Ind AS for financial instruments replica of IFRS?
Contractual cash flows & effective interest rate
Long-term financial liability classified as FVTPL
Credit adjusted effective interest rate
Effective rate of interest during the first-time adoption
Consequence of not de-recognising an asset after the sale
Designation of contracts deal a non-financial item on first time adoption
Recognition of financial instruments on first-time adoption
Gains and losses on a financial instrument
Gains and losses from liabilities designated as FVTPL
Measurement categories for financial assets
Difference between time value of money and modified time value of money